A "not so nice" review (from a person whose enjoyment of a music depends on just how idyllic the picture portrayed by the words is).
"
The Ministry of Defence": "they've sprayed graffiti in Arabic and balanced sticks in human shit".
"
Near the Memorials to Vietnam and Lincoln" offers bright uplift with the appearance of
mellotron and flute <...>.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________
"When she sings, on The Ministry of Defence, "they've sprayed graffiti in Arabic and balanced sticks in human shit", you're there all at once: amidst the heat and the fizzing tension of a war zone. But you’re adrift and off balance – what to do with this? Admire it? Perhaps. Sing along?
Enjoy? Flesh it out with your own - accompanying, complementary - response? As with much of this difficult record, it's a timely reminder that being hectored is rarely a very fulfilling experience." -
reviewer wants to be "fulfilled" by the song about trashed (former) government building? Well, sometimes music is intended to be unsettling and thought-provoking. And "enjoyment" is not always your sing-along-ey happy-pop-music-fan category - enjoyment could also be intellectual or esthetic.""What’s happened? Let's go and ask the Ministry of Social Affairs," she sings.
Let's not, you think.
That's probably not the answer, you think." -
And what is the answer then? It's government responsibility to improve people's lives so they wouldn't have to beg on the street. But I presume that reviewer's "answer" would be not to do anything and listen to something "life-affirming" to forget about these people ASAP.Once again, they want her to "
find some room for answers amidst the questions – or, at least, some hint of seeking to balance negative with positive". That's right - you just
HAVE TO find something positive about refugees camps, beggars, segregation, trashed buildings and empty houses, otherwise it's gonna depress civilized people. Also, Polly is not a politician to "find answers".
Oh yeah, they also say what "The Wheel" is "almost" as good as "Big Exit", which is a weird comparison in general IMO.