Top 3 PJ Albums

[Cartman]

Rid Of Me
To Bring You My Love
Let England Shake

----------
Is This Desire
White Chalk


Can't pick dude

[DeBarra]

Let England Shake is probably my 2nd favorite now!!!!



I can't stop listening to it and singing it everywhere I go.

I was in the grocery the other day singing "England's dancing days are done..." to myself.

And hearts that threaten to pop their boxes...


LOVE THIS RECORD.

Also, true story, I was listening to LES (the song) on the bus going to work and I looked out and saw two Army recruiters talking to some kids outside of the YMCA and it was right on the part where she goes - "Heavy stones are falling!" and it just fit so well.
I can't believe how immediate this album feels, while still feeling like it could have been written 2000 years ago. Timeless.

[olivier101]

OMG... Let England Shake is leading!

[cat on the wall]

Still waiting for my LES copy to arrive. I'm sure it'll be more then worth it, can't wait!

[The Dancer]

I made my decision (in chronological order without DHALP and AWAMWB):

Is This Desire?
White Chalk
Let England England Shake

...went hellwards...
...holding up their rifles high...

[Miss Pornstar]

TBYML
Desire
England Shake

[12fingered]

rid of me
to bring you my love
let england shake

[ernestina]

Let England Shake
Is this Desire?
To Bring You My Love

[March]

That took an embarrassingly long time to choose!

I settled on:

Is This Desire?
Uh Huh Her
Let England Shake- though I kept swapping this around with Rid of Me. LES wins today.

[Blackie]

.

[RedGretsch]

Rid of me
Raw, powerful and still an exciting experience. Personally love the way Albini recorded this.

Is this desire?
Incredibly captivating atmosphere.

White Chalk
Took a while to grow on me. Now I think it's one of the most beautiful albums ever made.

The list seems to change every once in a while. It's really only TBYML and SFTS that for some reason have always felt a bit...distant for me (still very good though!).

[Lilium]

1) White Chalk

Definitely the best one to me, made me cry so many times of nostalgy. A perfect atmosphere in it, no other artist is able to create something like this.

2) Is This Desire?

Full of emotion too.

3) To Bring You My Love

Classic.